Постановление Семнадцатого арбитражного апелляционного суда от 17.09.2008 по делу n А50-3215/2008. Постановление суда апелляционной инстанции: Изменить решение суда полностью и принять новый с/а

7520,886,4021,5813,3713,81129Луначарского97а2560120,05720.003410,0021827,312,5423,34130'Луначарского105197831370,31780,038960,02493151,7528,99129,69131Горького14510140,011570,003980,002555,522,964,72132Горького27132931550,2190,044080,02821104,5732,7989,37133Горького41235201800,5380,051190,03276256,9038,08219,56134Островского155497960,120,027300,0174757,3020,3148,97135Островского15А302900,0650,000000,0000031,040,0026,53136Островского213459480,070,013650,0087433,4310,1628,57137Островского27132091130,30560,032130,02057145,9223,91124,72138Окулова316783680,1440,019340,0123868,7614,3958,77139Окулова336370860,1440,024460,0156568,7618,2058,77140Орджоникидзе21916220,1860,006260,0040088,824,6575,91141Орджоникидзе276599800.12590,022750,0145660,1216,9351,38142Орджоникидзе746452710,1440,020190,0129268,7615,0258,77143Орджоникидзе76131811480,2560.042090,02694122,2431,31104,47144Орджоникидзе87110731550,24010,044080,02821114,6532,7997,98145Орджоникидзе9341401450,2430,041230,02639116,0330,6899,17146Орджоникидзе96180192200,3230,062560,04004154,2346,55131,82147Орджоникидзе101А6814610,1650,017350,0111078,7912,9167,34148Орджоникидзе101Б2812640,0940,018200,0116544,8913,5438,36149Попова25361562410,540,068530,04386257,8550,99220,37150Попова27329672390,540,067970,04350257,8550,57220,37151Попова55А1678280,04040,007960,0051019,295,9216,49152Попова577237630,1770,017920,0114784,5213,3372,23153Пушкина *1222892130,410,060570,03877195,7845,07167,32154Пушкина7450045690,7050,161810,10356336,64120,39287,71155Пушкина11437225680,7050,161530,10338336,64120,17287,71156Пушкина13\1351365850,5090,166360,10647243,05123,77207,72157Пушкина13\22682200,39350,000000,00000187,900,00160,59158Пушкина13\812527350,2830,009950,00637135,137,41115,49159Пушкина21438005700,580,162090,10374276,95120,60236,70160Пушкина23438005730,580,162950,10429276,95121,23236,70161Пушкина25431495160,580,146740,09391276,95109,17236,70162Пушкина27438505190,580.147590,09446276,95109,81236,70163Пушкина296967540,1640,015360,0098378,3111,4366,93164Пушкина357083730,13370,020760,0132963,8415,4454,56165Пушкина377650720,14430,020480,0131068,9015,2358,89166Пушкина       общ.108а79853160,2090,089860,0575199,8066,8685,29167Пушкина113566225851,1220,166360,10647535,76123,77457,89168Пушкина *115251841930,4910,054880,03513234,4540,83200,38169Пушкина116А10150350,230,009950,00637109,837,4193,86170Пушкина116Б203012100,3360,059720,03822160,4444,43137,12171Сибирская1211031700,41360,048340,03094197,4935,97168,79172Сибирская4А8582690,1780,019620,0125685,0014,6072,64173Сибирская7А3829260,10280,007390,0047349,095,5041,95174Сибирская22111800,02960,000000,0000014,130,0012,08175Сибирская3161609250,03910,007110,0045518,675,2915,96176Советская2210780500,2450,014220,00910116,9910,5899,98177Советская24А5584270,12670,007680,0049160,505,7151,71178Советская25 816738800,33760,022750,01456161,2016,93137,77179Советская288024530,14990,015070,0096571,5811,2161,17180Советская30143200,03540,000000,0000016,900,0014,45181Советская30а117200,02660,000000,0000012,700,0010,86182Советская32217100,03740,000000,0000017,860,0015,26183Советская3594400,03460,000000,0000016,520,0014,12184Советская39\1239761320,2980,037540,02402142,3027,93121,61185Советская39\21198800,1490,000000,0000071,150,0060,81186Советская39а214131230,5130,034980,02239244,9626,02209,36187Советская4874800,0150,000000,000007,160,006,12188Советская75252200,05720,000000,0000027,310,0023,34189Ш.Космонавтов14288300,060,000000,0000028,650,0024,49ИТОГО27123352685051,340097,676154,9127324514,895711,0520951,89

2,2920,822,5413,032,461,712,541,571,6226,18115,6528,9972,3928,059,5028,9917,9518,552,684,212,962,642,870,352,961,831,9029,6279,6932,7949,8931,746,5532,7920,3120,9934,40195,7838,08122,5636,8616,0938,0823,5924,3718,3543,6720,3127,3419,663,5920,3112,5813,000,0023,650.0014,810,001,940,000,000,009,1725,4710,1615,959,832,0910,166,296,5021,59111,2123,9169,6223,149,1423,9114,8115,3012,9952,4014,3932,8013,924,3114,398,919,2116,4352,4018,2032,8017,614,3118,2011,2711,654,2067,694,6542,374,505,564,652,882,9815,2945,8216,9328,6816,383,7616,9310,4810,8313,5752,4015,0232,8014,544,3115,029,309,6128,2893,1631,3158,3230,307,6531,3119,3920,0429,6287,3732,7954,6931,747.1832,7920,3120,9927,7188,4330,6855,3629,697,2730,6819,0019,6342,04117,5446,5573,5845,059,6646,5528,8329,7911,6660,0412,9137,5912,494,9312,917,998,2612,2334,2113,5421,4113,102,8113,548,398,6746,06196,5150,99123,0149,3416,1550,9931,5832,6345,67196,5150,57123,0148,9416,1550,5731,3232,365,3514,705,929,205,731,215,923,673,7912,0464,4113,3340,3212,905,2913,338,268,5340,70149,2045,0793,4043,6112,2645,0727,9128,84108,74256,55120,39160,60116,5021,08120,3974,5677,05108,54256,55120,17160,60116,3021,08120,1774,4376,91111,79185,23123,77115,95119,7815,22123,7776,6679,210,00143,190,0089,640,0011,770,000,000,006,69102,987,4164,477,178,467,414,594,74108,93211,06120,60132,12116,7117,34120,6074,6977,18109,50211,06121,23132,12117,3217,34121,2375,0977,5998,61211,06109,17132,12105,6517,34109,1767,6269,8799,18211,06109,81132,12106,2717,34109,8168,0170,2810,3259,6811,4337,3611,064.9011,437,087,3113,9548,6515,4430,4614,954,0015,449,579,8813,7652,5115,2332,8714,744,3115,239,439,7560,3976,0666,8647,6164,706,2566,8641,4142,79111,79408,30123,77255,59119,7833,55123,7776,6679,2136,88178,6740,83111,8539,5214,6840,8325,2926,136,6983,707,4152,397,176,887,414,594,7440,13122,2744,4376,5443,0010,0544,4327,5228,4432,49150,5135,9794,2234,8112,3735,9722,2823,0213,1964,7714,6040,5514,135,3214,609,049,344,9737,415,5023,425,323,075,503,413,520,0010,770,006,740,000,890,000,000,004,7814,235,298,915,121,175,293,283,399,5689,1610,5855,8110,247,3310,586,556,775,1646,115,7128,865,533,795,713,543,6615,29122,8516,9376,9116,3810,0916,9310,4810,8310,1354,5511,2134,1510,854,4811,216,957,180,0012,880,008,060,001,060,000,000,000,009,680,006,060,000,800,000,000,000,0013,610,008,520,001,120,000,000,000,0012,590,007,880,001,030,000,000,0025,23108,4427,9367,8827,038,9127,9317,3017,870,0054,220,0033,940,004,460,000,000,0023,51186,6826,02116,8625,1815,3426,0216,1216,660,005,460,003,420,000,450,000,000,000,0020,820,0013,030,001,710,000,000,000,0021,830,0013,671,790,000,000,005158,3718682,665711,0511695,275526,831535,075711,0503537,1703655,07августСкалсентябрь,Гкалоктябрь, Гк<Гкалноябрь, ГкаГкалдекабрь, ГкГкалИтого, ГкалГВСотоплениеГВСотоплениеГВСотоплениеГВСотоплениеГВСОтоплениеГВСВсего74432,7720251,6744344,3720442,374415,308,2723,1463,6523,9187,1123,14111,9023,91652,26255,95908,2111,104,7116,7936,2317,3549,5816,7963,6917,35371,25185.74556,9816,9314,9825,59115,2326,45157,6925,59202,5726,451180,77283,141463,908,945,9113,5145,4413,9662,1813,5179,8813,96465,60149,50615,1011,246,6516,9951,1817,5670,0316,9989,9617,56524,39188,00712,397,274,0010,9930,7511,3542,0710,9954,0511,35315,04121.56436,6025,598,1138,7062,4039,9985,3938,70109,6939,99639,37428,101067,4741,9812,6563,4797,2965,59133,1463,47171,0465,59996,95702,181699,130.000,720,005,540.007,570,009,730,0056,720,0056,7241,3023,9762,45184,4264,53252,3762,45324,2164,531889,75690,852580,6018,6910,4628,2680,5129,20110,1828,26141.5429,20824,99312,581137,5724,7816,3537,47125,8038,72172,1537,47221.1538,721289,05414,511703,5635,6114,7853,85113,7255,64155,6253,85199,9255,641165,30595,721761,020,007,000,0053,840,0073,680,0094,650,00551,710.00551,710,001,080,008,300,0011,360,0014,600,0085,080,0085,080,000,780,006,040,008,260,0010,620,0061,870.0061,879,615,1314,5439,5015,0254,0614,5469,4415,02404,76160,82565,580,001,380,0010,590,0014,500,0018,620,00108,540,00108,540,004,080,0031,420,0043,000,0055,240,00322,000,00322,0015,308,5623,1465,8923,9190,1723,14115,8423,91675,20255,95931,1618,558,4928,0565,3228,9989,3828,05114,8228,99669,27310,32979,5913,816,2220,8847,8321,5865,4520,8884,0821,58490,10231.04721,1429,6512,4944,8496,1146,33131,5244,84168,9646,33984,83496,051480,890,0012,680,0097,550,00133,490,00171,480,00999,530,00999,5341,4312,0162,6592,3964,74126,4362,65162,4164,74946,68693,111639,7935,5918,1253,82139,3955,61190,7453,82245,0355,611428,27595,392023,6629,797,4945,0557,6246,5578,8445,05101,2946,55590,38498,321088,7032,2318,1248.73139,3950,35190,7448,73245,0350,351428,27539,091967,3626,545,3940,1341,4441,4756,7140,1372,8541,47424,61443,96868,570,007,910,0060,890,0083,320,00107,040,00623,900,00623,9024,245,3936,6541,4437,8756,7136,6572,8537,87424,61405,45830,060,007,910,0060,890,0083,320,00107,040,00623,900,00623,9027.767,9141,9760,8943,3783,3241,97107,0443,37623,90464,341088,2427.765,4041,9741,5143,3756,8141,9772,9843,37425,39464,34889,7316,799,8725,3975,9126,24103,8825,39133,4426,24777,81280,871058,686,912,7110,4420,8610,7928,5410,4436,6710,79213,72115,52329,2410,024,1915,1532,2015,6644,0715,1556,6115,66330,00167,62497,6116,117,1324,3754,8525,1875,0624,3796,4225,18562,03269,54831,5738,4119,6558,08151,1660,02206,8658,08265,7360,021548,92642,532191,4536,4817,5955,17135,3457,00185,2055,17237,9157,001386,76610,281997,0430,2024,6245,66189,4547,18259,2645,66333,0547,181941,31505,112446,4214,089,0921,2969,9422,0095,7221,29122,9622,00716,71235,57952,287,454,8411,2637,2411,6450,9611,2665,4611,64381,56124,58506,140,271,150,418,880,4212,150,4115,610,4291,014,5395,549,215,2013,9240,0014,3954,7413,9270,3314,39409,92154,03563,940,000,190,001,450,001,990,002,550,0014,880,0014,880,001,570,0012,080,0016,530,0021,230,00123,750,00123,750,000,840,006,470,008,850,0011,370,0066,260,0066,260,001,040,007,980,0010,910,0014,020,0081,730,0081,730,002,740,0021,110,0028,890,0037,110,00216,300,00216,300,001,370,0010,520,0014,390,0018,490,00107,760,00107,760,005,720,0044,030,0060,250,0077,400,00451,170,00451,170,001,710,0013,130,0017,970,0023,090,00134,580,00134,580,001,480,0011,400,0015,600,0020,040,00116,790,00116,790,001,720,0013,210,0018,080,0023,220,00135,350,00135,350,000,920,007,070,009,670,0012,430,0072,440,0072,440,001,150,008,860,0012,120,0015,570,0090,750,0090,7531,9618,3448,32141,1549,93193,1548,32248,1349,931446,31534,561980,8776,3725,95115,48199,64119,33273,20115,48350,97119,332045,721277,513323,2311,652,6617,6120,4318.2027,9617,6135,9118,20209,34194,80404,140,004,220,0032.460,0044,410,0057,060,00332.570,00332,5716,617,0325,1254,0925,9574,0225,1295,0525,95554,29277,85832,14

0,002,810,0021,640,0029,610,0038,040,00221,720,00221,72       42,7911,5364,7088,7166,86121,4064,70155,9566,86909,04715,771624,8010,028,3115,1563,9115,6687,4515,15112,3415,66654,84167,62822,4515,848,6023,9666,1724,7590,5523,96116,3224,75678,04265,01943,0514,358,2721,7063,6522,4387,1121,70111,9022,43652,26240,10892,3671,5025,95108,11199.64111,71273,20108,11350,97111,712045,721195,963241,6971,7725,95108,52199,64112,13273,20108,52350,97112,132045,721200,493246,2225,3613,8038,35106,1539,62145,2638,35186,6139,621087,70424,221511,9274,6123,08112,82177,60116,58243,04112,82312,22116,581819,881248,063067,9470,0125,95105,86199,64109,38273,20105,86350,97109,382045,721171,053216,7724,9213,8037,67106,1538,93145,2637,67186,6138,931087,70416,771504,4826,5412,5840,1396,7741,47132,4240,13170,1141,47991,54443,961435,4925,4612,8238,4998,6339,78134,9738,49173,3839,781010,62425,841436,4518,017,5827,2358,3028,1479,7727,23102,4828,14597,35301,26898.6022,8812,5134,6096,2635,76131,7334,60169,2235,76986,38382,801369,1813,815,2520,8840,3821,5855,2620,8870,9921,58413,79231,04644,825,155,767,7844,288,0460,607,7877,848,04453,7586,07539,8215,447,3223,3456,3624,1277,1223,3499,0824,12577,49258,22835,7119,098,8628,8768,1829,8393,3128,87119,8629,83698,67319,381018,0412,468,5018,8465,4219,4689,5218,84115,0019,46670,31208,39878,6912,466,9618,8453,5419,4673,2718,8494,1219,46548,62208,39757,0111,243,9516,9930,3917,5641,5916,9953,4317,56311,43188,00499,4417,337,9026,2160,8127,0883,2226,21106,9027,08623.13289,93913,0617,606,7526,6251,9327,5071,0626,6291,2927,50532,12294,46826,586,914,3210,4433,2110,7945,4510,4458,3810,79340,31115,52455,8329,5210,2344,6478,7046,12107,7044,64138,3546.12806,43493,791300,2231,2810,2347,3078,7048,87107,7047,30138,3548,87806,43523,231329,6637,2418,5756,31142,9158,18195,5656,31251,2358,181464,36622,902087,2617,065,9725,8045,9426,6662,8725.8080,7626,66470,76285,40756,1618,426,4727,8549,8228,7768,1727,8587,5828,77510,46308,05818,5115,716,4723,7549,8224,5468,1723,7587,5824,54510,46262,75773,2118,2810,3527,6479,6328,56108,9727,64139,9928,56815,97305,791121,7510,436,4215,7749,4116,2967,6215,7786,8716,29506,34174,41680,7538,1113,6157,63104,7259,55143,3057,63184,0959,551073,01637,571710,5735,0718,9753,03145,9354,80199,6953,03256,5354,801495,30^586,662081,959,884,9114,9537,7415,4451,6514,9566,3515,44386,72165,35552,079,884,7114,9536,2115,4449,5414,9563,6515,44370,99165.35536,348,809,1613,3170,4513,7596,4013,31123,8413,75721,87147,23869,100,000,630,004,870,006,660,008,560,0049,890,0049,8918,558,0128,0561,6428,9984,3528,05108,3628,99631,63310,32941,957,724,0511,6731,1712,0642,6611,6754,8012,06319,43129,11448,5413,817,5920,8858,3721,5879,8820,88102,6121,58598,12231,04829,1650,9122,3476,99171,8979,55235,2376,99302,1879,551761,36851,672613,0328,7111,7443,4190,3544,85123,6443,41158,8344,85925,80480,201405,9910,568,9515,9768,8916,5094,2715,97121,1016,50705,88176,68882,5619,778,3729,8964,4130,8988,1429,89113,2330,89659,99330,70990,7015,848,3723,9664,4124,7588,1423,96113,2324,75659.99265,01925,0118,967,4228,6757,0629,6278,0928,67100,3129,62584,71317,11901,8223,709,8135,8375,4837,03103,2935,83132,6937,03773,43396,391169,8224,379,8836,8675,9838,08103,9836,86133,5738,08778,59407,711186,3016,794,7925,3936,8826,2450,4725,3964,8426,24377,95280,87658,8223,7011,8035,8390,8337,03124,2935,83159,6737,03930,69396,391327,084,063,096,1423,806,3532,576,1441,846,35243,8967,95311,8410,708,2116,1863,1516,7186,4216,18111,0216,71647,10178,94826,0411,788,2117,8163,1518,4186,4217,81111,0218,41647,10197,06844,1717,607,3026,6256,1827,5076,8826,6298,7727,50575,69294,46870,153,112,814,7121,614,8729,584,7137,994,87221,4652,10273,560,0014,290,00109,950,00150,460,00193,290,001126,630,001126,6379,4813,44120,19103,41124,19141,51120,19181,79124,191059,601329,602389,2011,7813,0817,81100,6418,41137,7217,81176,9218,411031,24197,061228,309,615,1314,5439,4815,0254.0214,5469,4015,02404,50160,82565,3210,837,2216,3855,5816,9376,0616,3897,7016,93569,50181,21750,7110,434,2115,7732,4116,2944,3515,7756,9716,29332,06174,41506,4782,6028,35124,90218,14129,06298,51124,90383,47129,062235,211381,703616,9173,8022,30111,59171,59115,31234,81111,59301,65115,311758,261234,472992,7313,817,0020,8853,8421,5873,6820,8894,6521,58551,71231,04782,75

1,621,872,4614,392,5419,692,4625,302,54147,4727,18174,65,18,5510,3928,0579,9628,99109,4228,05140,5628,99819,32310,321129,641,900,382,872,912,963,982,875,122,9629,8331,7161,5420,997,1631,7455,1032,7975,4031,7496,8632,79564,60351,09915,6924,3717,5936,86135,3638,08185.2336,86237,9638,081387,02407,711794,7313,003,9219,6630,1920,3141,3219,6653,0820,31309,37217,45526,820,002,130.0016,350,0022,380,0028,750,00167,580,00167,586,502,299,8317,6110,1624,109,8330,9610,16180,47108,72289,1915,309,9923,1476,8923,91105,2223,14135,1723,91787,87255,951043,829,214,7113,9236,2314,3949,5813,9263,6914,39371,25154,03525,2711,654,7117,6136,2318,2049,5817,6163,6918,20371,25194,80566,042,986,084,5046,804,6564,044,5082,274,65479,5349,83529,3610,834,1216,3831,6816,9343,3516,3855,6916,93324,58181,21505,799,614,7114,5436,2315,0249,5814,5463,6915,02371,25160,82532,0720,048,3730,3064,4131,3188,1430,30113,2331,31659,99335,23995,2320,997,8531,7460,4132.7982,6731,74106,2032,79619,00351,09970,0919,637,9529,6961,1430,6883,6629,69107,4830,68626,48328,44954,9229,7910,5645,0581,2746,55111,2145,05142,8646,55832,73498,321331,048,265,4012,4941,5112,9156,8112,4972,9812,91425,39138,17563,568,673,0713,1023,6513,5432,3613,1041,5813,54242,34144,97387,3132,6317,6649,34135,8650,99185,9249,34238,8450.991392,17545,881938,0632,3617,6648,94135,8650,57185,9248,94238,8450,571392,17541,351933,533,791,325,7310,165,9213,915,7317,875,92104,1663,42167,588,535,7912,9044,5313,3360,9412,9078,2913,33456,32142,70599,0228,8413,4143,61103,1645,07141,1643,61181,3445,071057,02482,461539,4877,0523,05116,50177,38120,39242,73116,50311,82120,391817,561288,833106,3976,9123,05116,30177,38120,17242,73116,30311,82120,171817,561286,573104,1379,2116,64119,78128,06123,77175,25119,78225,13123,771312,251325,072637,330,0012,870,0099,000,00135,480,00174,050,001014,480,001014,484,749,257,1771,207,4197,447,17125,177,41729,6079,28808,8877,1818,97116,71145,93120,60199,69116,71256,53120,601495,301291,102786,3977,5918,97117,32145,93121,23199,69117,32256.53121,231495,301297,892793,1969,8718,97105,65145,93109,17199,69105,65256,53109,171495,301168,782664,0870,2818,97106.27145,93109,81199,69106,27256,53109,811495,301175,582670,887,315,3611,0641,2611,4356,4711,0672,5411,43422,81122,31545,129,884,3714,9533,6415,4446,0314,9559,1415,44344,69165,35510,049,754.7214,7436,3115,2349,6814,7463,8215,23372,02163,09535,1142.796,8364,7052,5866,8671,9664,7092,4466,86538,82715,771254,5979,2136,69119,78282,30123,77386,30119,78496,26123,772892,631325,074217,7026,1316,0639,52123,5440,83169,0539,52217,1740,831265,85437,161703,014,747,527,1757,877,4179,197,17101,737,41592,9679,28672,2428,4410,9943,0084,5444,43115,6843,00148,6144,43866,24475,671341,9123,0213,5234,81104,0635,97142,4034,81182,9435,971066,30385,061451,379,345,8214,1344,7814,6061,2914,1378,7314,60458,90156,29615,193,523,365,3225,865,5035,395,3245,475.50265,0358,89323,920,000,970,007,450,0010,190,0013,090,0076,310,0076,313,391,285,129,845,2913,465,1217,295,29100,8056,63157,436,778,0110,2461,6410,5884,3510,24108,3610,58631,63113,25744,893,664,145,5331,885,7143,625,5356,045,71326,6561,16387,8010,8311,0416,3884,9416,93116,2416,38149,3216,93870,37181,211051,577,184,9010,8537,7111,2151,6110,8566,3011,21386,46120,05506,510,001,160,008,910,0012,190,0015,660,0091,260,0091,260,000,870,006,690,009,160,0011,770,0068,580,0068,580,001,220,009,410,0012,880,0016,540,0096,420,00